Totonnos, New York City

Address 1524 Neptune Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11224 Map, Tel 718-372-8606 Call, Hours Call for hours Website

Several years ago (pre-kids) we took a tour of eight New York pizza places in a single day, tasting each, and after lots of analysis, a spredsheet, and lots of discussion decided that Totonnos had the best pizza. This location, on Coney Island, is the original and the best.